What I look for in an Airbnb listing after 100+ stays

Reading Time: 4 min

At this point, I’ve booked Airbnbs on every continent except Antarctica. I’ve stayed in more than 100 of them, from a magical riad in Morocco and a stunning beach house in Uruguay to a cozy mountain cabin in the Smoky Mountains.

After enough great stays — along with a few that looked much better online than they did in person — I’ve learned that choosing the right Airbnb is absolutely a skill. I still love hotels for points stays, suite upgrades, free breakfast, and convenience, and there are ways to earn points on Airbnb bookings, too. But for family vacations, longer stays, remote destinations, or trips where space really matters, Airbnb can be incredible — if you know what to look for.

Airbnb ratings are very different from hotel or Tripadvisor ratings. A 4.5 out of 5 might sound good, but in the Airbnb world, that can sometimes be a warning sign.

Personally, I prioritize properties with ratings of 4.9 or higher and usually avoid brand-new listings without reviews. A beautiful listing doesn’t mean much without a proven track record from actual guests.

I also immediately sort reviews by “lowest rated” to see just how bad things really were. If multiple guests mention noise, cleanliness issues, or uncomfortable beds, I assume there’s probably truth to it. That said, I don’t overreact to isolated complaints or obvious nitpicking — I just want to make sure the same problems aren’t recurring.

Review length tells me something, too. Quick, generic reviews aren’t disqualifying on their own, but when guests consistently go on at length about the property and the host, that enthusiasm is hard to manufacture.

The quality of the photos and what they actually show matter a lot. If the photos are blurry, rushed, poorly framed, or don’t really show the space well, that’s usually a red flag for me. I also pay close attention to what the listing doesn’t show.

For example, if a property says it sleeps six guests but I only see photos of two beds, I immediately start wondering what’s missing. The same goes for kitchens, bathrooms, outdoor spaces, or other important areas that barely appear in the listing.

In my experience, the way a host presents the property usually says a lot about how detail-oriented they’ll be during the actual stay.

This is probably my biggest indicator when booking an Airbnb.

Even if the listing describes everything in detail, I still message the host before booking. I’ll introduce myself and ask something simple about the property or neighborhood.

Honestly, half the time I’m not even asking for the answer; I’m trying to get a feel for the host. I want to see how quickly they reply, how thorough they are, and whether the communication feels thoughtful and professional. Hosts who communicate well before the stay usually put the same level of care into the guest experience itself.

Before reserving an Airbnb, I spend almost as much time researching the neighborhood as I do the property itself. I’ll use Airbnb’s map feature to check nearby landmarks, restaurants, grocery stores, and overall walkability, then head over to Google Maps to see if I can spot some street views so I can physically see what the location is actually like.

One thing many travelers don’t realize is that Airbnb’s map is imprecise on purpose. By default, Airbnb shows a general location — a circle covering roughly a half-mile radius around the address — and hosts have to opt in to a more specific pin. You don’t get the street address until the reservation is confirmed.

One trick I use is asking the host how far the property is from a specific landmark or nearby building. Sometimes hosts will even share the name of the apartment complex or community, which makes it much easier to properly evaluate the location.

None of this adds much time — maybe 15 extra minutes before you hit book. But that’s usually the difference between the stay you’re still telling people about a year later and the one you spend three nights trying to escape.